Is the ruling of a violation correct if A-1 excessively swings their arms and elbows without contact?

In basketball, a violation typically refers to an infraction of the rules that does not involve contact with an opponent. In this case, if A-1 excessively swings their arms and elbows without making contact, it generally constitutes a violation due to the potential for dangerous play or unsportsmanlike conduct. Excessive swinging can be seen as an attempt to gain an unfair advantage or disrupt the offensive flow, which is taken seriously by officials.

The rule is designed to maintain the integrity of the game and ensure the safety of all players. Even without contact, such behavior can be deemed as violating the spirit of the rules, as players are expected to demonstrate respect and control during the game. Recognizing this act as a violation serves to promote sportsmanship and player safety on the court. Therefore, ruling it as a violation is indeed correct.